You signed in with another tab or window. Reload to refresh your session.You signed out in another tab or window. Reload to refresh your session.You switched accounts on another tab or window. Reload to refresh your session.Dismiss alert
Hi @thombergs, thanks for a great book, it was really a great eye-opener to bring clean architecture into practice.
In general, I have problems to connect the dots in one topic: How does exception handling conceptionally fit into the picture?
For example the LoadAccountPort defines loadAccount interface/communication channel but the concrete adapter implementation throws an EntityNotFoundException if an account is not found. Instead of an implementation detail isn't this a property of the communication port, which all adapters of this port should comply with? Or asked the other way round, how can I force/lead implementeers of port interfaces to throw "expected" exceptions?
Another area where I am not sure about is global error handling: Say I want that the EntityNotFoundException should relate to a 404 and the service ThresholdExceededException should lead to a 403, both with a default error response body (i.e based on rfc7807). If I create now a global error handler in the web adapter, isn't then also the web adapter implementation depending on implementation details (EntityNotFoundException) of the implementation detail of another out adapter impl.?
The text was updated successfully, but these errors were encountered:
Hi @thombergs, thanks for a great book, it was really a great eye-opener to bring clean architecture into practice.
In general, I have problems to connect the dots in one topic: How does exception handling conceptionally fit into the picture?
For example the LoadAccountPort defines loadAccount interface/communication channel but the concrete adapter implementation throws an EntityNotFoundException if an account is not found. Instead of an implementation detail isn't this a property of the communication port, which all adapters of this port should comply with? Or asked the other way round, how can I force/lead implementeers of port interfaces to throw "expected" exceptions?
Another area where I am not sure about is global error handling: Say I want that the EntityNotFoundException should relate to a 404 and the service ThresholdExceededException should lead to a 403, both with a default error response body (i.e based on rfc7807). If I create now a global error handler in the web adapter, isn't then also the web adapter implementation depending on implementation details (EntityNotFoundException) of the implementation detail of another out adapter impl.?
The text was updated successfully, but these errors were encountered: