KeyError: 'id' missing

[mxia9416]

When input a playlist url it will report KeyError 'id'', Metube works fine when input is a single video.
In addition, I tried the same playlist url with newest release of yt-dlp(win11) fork provided in readme and it worked fine, so I create an issue ticket here.
Log below:

DEBUG:ytdl:Processing as a video                                                 
ERROR:aiohttp.server:Error handling request                                      
Traceback (most recent call last):                                               
  File "/usr/local/lib/python3.11/site-packages/aiohttp/web_protocol.py", line 47
7, in _handle_request                                                            
    resp = await request_handler(request)                                                                              
  File "/usr/local/lib/python3.11/site-packages/aiohttp/web_app.py", line 559, in
 _handle                                                                         
    return await handler(request)                                                                                               
  File "/app/app/main.py", line 146, in add                                      
    status = await dqueue.add(url, quality, format, folder, custom_name_prefix, p
laylist_strict_mode, playlist_item_limit, auto_start)                                                
  File "/app/app/ytdl.py", line 337, in add                                      
    return await self.__add_entry(entry, quality, format, folder, custom_name_pre
fix, playlist_strict_mode, playlist_item_limit, auto_start, already)                      
  File "/app/app/ytdl.py", line 289, in __add_entry                              
    results.append(await self.__add_entry(etr, quality, format, folder, custom_na
me_prefix, playlist_strict_mode, playlist_item_limit, auto_start, already))      
  File "/app/app/ytdl.py", line 295, in __add_entry                              
    if not self.queue.exists(entry['id']):                                                            
KeyError: 'id'          

[PikuZheng]

Are you using the web ui to add the list or posting the list directly to the /add ?

[mxia9416]

I used webui, Metube itself is running on synology nas.
For the test I mentioned, I directly run ytdlp without ANY UI (Metube) through command line on my win11 pc use the same setting, which added a name template including 'id' field. The same setting works fine with Metube before.

Are you using the web ui to add the list or posting the list directly to the /add ?

[PikuZheng]

yt-dlp command line has different behavior than embedded yt-dlp.

to make it clear, are you means a playlist works fine with the old version of metube, but the new one doesn't work? can you provide a link for test?

[mxia9416]

Yes, I set up Metube in my NAS like a years ago or so and it has been working without issue. I can't recall the exact version that cause this issue as I set up an auto update of the Metube docker container, I also don't use it daily, maybe every once in 2 months, so I'm also surprised to find it stopped working today. My docker setting are below:

Testing list link will report error below:

The individual video in the list downloads fine.

[PikuZheng]

啊 是b站

[mxia9416]

其实我是下P站的时候发现会报错，但感觉影响不好（
后来发现B站也不行，之前都是没问题的

[PikuZheng]

这个问题根源大概是程序本来设计上是给youtube用的，其他视频网站有的是拿不到id。大体上我能猜到哪个提交改了这个地方。不过简单的方法是打开Strict Playlist mode

[mxia9416]

试了一下，Strict Playlist mode可以把list里面的视频当成单独视频下载。
不过因为我的需求是输入list的url然后批量下载一个list里面的所有视频，这个方法可能并不适用。
我先用yt-dlp本体来下载，期待metube能修复这个问题 。

[PikuZheng]

@labmonkey could you please look into this issue? The 'id' attribute seems to be missing here

metube/app/ytdl.py

Line 289 in c4561dc

results.append(await self.__add_entry(etr, quality, format, folder, custom_name_prefix, playlist_strict_mode, playlist_item_limit, auto_start, already))

[PikuZheng]

试了一下，Strict Playlist mode可以把list里面的视频当成单独视频下载。 不过因为我的需求是输入list的url然后批量下载一个list里面的所有视频，这个方法可能并不适用。 我先用yt-dlp本体来下载，期待metube能修复这个问题 。

它会一个个全下载下来的，但是下载列表中只有一行。
或者你回退到这个版本试试 ghcr.io/alexta69/metube:2024-08-07

[mxia9416]

metube:2024-08-07

Version metube:2024-08-07 has no issue and acts like before.
I'll keep on this version and pause auto-update until it's solved.
Thanks!